Re: Should helper functions be members?

When should a function be a private member, and when simply a standalone
function in the .cpp file?

I'm in the middle of writing a class which bridges between two packages,
and so I need some helper functions to convert between the types used,
in particular between 'unsigned long long' and a ValidityKey which is
like an unsigned long long but only goes up to 2^63 -1.
(Please dont flame me for using unsigned long long, I know its not
standard, but I'm stuck with it).

So I could do the following (this example is not complete - and is just
off the top of my head - , just highlighting the salient points)

in the .h file:
==============

//fwd decl
namespace pkg1{
  class ValidityKey;
}

class CoolInterface{
  private:
    pkg1::ValidityKey convertToKey(const longlongKey);

};

and then put the implementation in the .cpp file as usual:

in the .cpp file
================

#include "pkg1/ValidityKey.h"
#include "pkg1/ValidityKeyException.h"

pkg1::ValidityKey CoolInterface::convertToKey(const longlongKey){
   if (longlongKey > ValidityKey::max()) //max() is 2^63 -1
   {
    std::cerr<<"CoolInterfaceError: key is too big"<<std::endl;
    throw(pkg1::ValidityKeyException("convertToKey",longlongKey));
   } else {
    return ValidityKey(longlongKey);//this constructor exists
   }
}